The use of Information
and Communication Technology (ICT) in Dutch education is lagging behind
expectation and desire. Hence, the advisory ‘Commitee On Multimedia In Teacher
Training’ (COMMITT, at present PROMMITT), established by the Dutch Minister of
Education, has drawn up recommendations on the design of the learning process
in the future and the role of ICT to support this process, with a focus on
teacher training. The committee argues for a powerful role of teacher training
in the process of educational innovation and the implementation of ICT. The
teacher training institutes are providing the teachers of the future and the
committee assumes that teachers are the keyfigures in arranging learning
processes. The institutes, therefore, have to anticipate new developments and
prepare prospective teachers for their future role. The nature and extent to
which ICT is being used in education is considered to be a result of synergy
between ‘top-down’ and ‘bottom up’ processes. In the latter especially, a contribution
of the teacher training institutes can be expected. According to commit,
teacher training institutes therefore have to shift their focus from dealing
with present education to that of ‘future education’.
Within the PROMMITT
action-programme, Stoas Research analyses the future educational practices of
the vet-professional. Accordingly, teachers can be as much as possible prepared
and thus, can encourage the implementation of ICT in secondary vocational education.
The main research
question is: What is the teachers’ prospective role in a richly ICT-designed
learning environment and what competences are required for this role?
1.2 Research questions
The following questions
are posed in our study:
- What are the consequences of (the use of) ICT in
occupational practice on the attainment targets and curriculum of
secondary (agricultural) vocational education?
- What are the interactions between new educational
insights and the use of ICT in educational practice?
- What are the consequences of an ‘ICT-integrated’
curriculum (in secondary vocational education) and the use of ICT on the
job of the (future) vet professional?
- What is the new – ICT-integrated – job profile of the
VET-professional, based on which the attainment targets and the curriculum
of the teacher training can be altered?
- Before presenting the research methods and results, we
will discuss the concept of a richly ICT-designed learning environment and
the status quo of the use of ICT in Dutch vocational education.
1.3 ICT in dutch
vocational education
ICT is a generic term
referring to technologies which are being used for collecting, storing, editing
and passing on information in various forms (SER, 1997). A personal computer is
the best known example of the use of ICT in education, but the term multimedia
is also frequently used. Multimedia can be interpreted as a combination of data
carriers, for example video, CD-ROM, floppy disc and Internet and software in which
the possibility for an interactive approach is offered (Smeets, 1996).
Generally, the following
functions of the use of ICT in education are described in literature (SER,
1998, Moonen and Kommers, 1995, Pilot, 1998).
1.
ICT as object. It refers
to learning about ICT. Mostly organised in a specific course. What is being
learned depends on the type of education and the level of the students.
Education prepares students for the use of ICT in education, future occupation
and social life.
2.
ICT as an ‘assisting
tool’. ICT is used as a tool, for example while making assignments, collecting
data and documentation, communicating and conducting research. Typically, ICT
is used independently from the subject matter.
3.
ICT as a medium for
teaching and learning. This refers tot ICT as a tool for teaching and learning
itself, the medium through which teachers can teach and learners can learn. It
appears in many different forms, such as drill and practice exercises, in
simulations and educational networks.
4.
ICT as a tool for
organisation and management in schools.
In 1998, OCTO (a Dutch
educational research institute) studied the extent in which ICT is actually
being used for realising the above-mentioned functions. The research was
carried out on all educational levels in The Netherlands. The present work
concentrates on vocational education.
However, given the lack
of a sufficient response, a reliable image for the entire sector cannot be
given, but an impression of the status quo of the use of ICT in vocational
education is possible. (Janssen Reinen, 1999). ICT is never being used as a
(learning) objective by 33 of 55 teachers; 27 teachers do not use ICT as
teaching material and 21 teachers do not use ICT as an aid. If the computer is
being used, then this is mainly for the purpose of word processing and
exercising the lessons. Thus, it seems that the computer is being used
especially for supporting more traditional educational settings (Janssen
Reinen, 1999).
We can conclude (present
work and uncited literature) that ICT has many technical possibilities, but
that the real innovative use of ICT is not broadly adopted in Dutch vocational
education.
1.4 Research method
This paper will discuss
the questions concerning ICT and education (not ICT in occupational practice).
Several methods of data collection were used for this component of the project.
As described in the
first paragraph, the main research question concerned the future learning
environment and the teacher’s prospective role. To know more about this future,
several scenarios on future developments in education have been studied.
Because many scenarios have already been completed, we did not perform our own
study, but used the available literature (e.g. Ter Woude, 1996, Van den Dool
e.a., 1998, Pilot e.a., 1996). Published studies were scanned especially for
the role and impact of ICT. Furthermore, experts were heard about this topic.
We gathered additional information on the role of the teacher by visiting
schools where ICT is already being used ‘extensively’. Information on
organisational level was gathered and interviews were conducted with teachers.
These interviews were aimed AT the teacher’s tasks, roles and required
competences to fulfil these tasks and roles properly. In addition, literature
on job profiles of teachers and implementation literature was studied.

